Conifr Logo

AI + Humans = Perfect DUO for SEO (SaaS Math)

By
Michael Ter Mors
2/20/2025

Want to improve your SEO?

Contact us today to discuss an SEO program for your brand.
Contact Us

How many times do you hear “AI” every day?

It feels like every SaaS company is using it, talking about it, or figuring out how to integrate it more effectively. And for good reason - AI is transforming SEO by automating tasks, analyzing data, and generating content at scale, but without human creativity, strategy, and critical thinking, your SEO will fall flat. The best results come when AI and human expertise work together.

Let’s break down why this combo is the key to building SEO campaigns that actually drive results.

Why AI Alone Isn’t Enough for SaaS SEO Success

AI is an incredible tool, but it works best when paired with human insight. Here’s why SaaS companies should use AI to enhance their SEO efforts, rather than relying on it entirely:

1. AI Needs Human-Guided Industry & Customer Insights

AI is excellent at analyzing search trends and competitor data, but it doesn’t automatically understand the nuances of your target audience. It needs input to:

  • Recognize the specific pain points your SaaS product solves.
  • Identify the emotional triggers that drive customer decisions.
  • Stay on top of evolving conversations in niche SaaS communities (like Product Hunt or Indie Hackers).

Source: The Futurum Group

When you provide AI with this context, it becomes far more effective in shaping content that resonates with your audience and aligns with their needs.

2. AI-Generated Content Needs Refinement for Engagement

AI can generate content quickly, but without human oversight, it often lacks depth, originality, and a brand voice. To make AI-written content work, it’s essential to:

  • Infuse storytelling and brand personality into the content.
  • Refine AI drafts with unique insights and real-world examples.
  • Ensure content goes beyond surface-level information to provide real value.
Bad Example of AI Generated Content
Good Example of AI Generated Content

For example, if AI generates a post on “SaaS Pricing Strategies,” it might list generic pricing models. A human expert can take it further by adding case studies, comparisons, and actionable insights that make the content truly valuable.

3. AI Can’t Fully Understand Search Intent Without Human Input

SEO success depends on understanding the intent behind searches. AI can categorize queries, but it doesn’t always grasp the subtle shifts in intent. Consider these examples:

  • A user searching "best CRM software" wants comparisons and feature breakdowns.
  • A search for "HubSpot vs. Salesforce" means they’re deep in the decision-making stage.
  • Someone googling "how to automate sales emails" needs actionable steps, not a sales pitch.

Source: Seer Interactive

Human writers and strategists know how to tailor content accordingly, ensuring it meets searchers where they are in the funnel.

4. AI Can Enhance Link-Building but Not Replace Human Strategy

Backlinks are still a massive SEO ranking factor, but AI can’t:

  • Build relationships with industry blogs and influencers.
  • Create link-worthy content that stands out.
  • Understand the nuances of personalized outreach.

Source: Ahrefs

AI can assist in outreach strategy, but human creativity and networking remain essential for high-quality link acquisition.

5. AI Helps Adapt to SEO Changes, but Humans Drive Innovation

Google’s algorithms change constantly, and while AI tools can adapt to some updates, they can’t predict why changes are happening. Human SEOs:

  • Stay ahead by analyzing trends from experts and communities.
  • Adjust strategies proactively, instead of just reacting.
  • Innovate instead of just optimizing what already exists.

Take Google’s Helpful Content Update, for example - many AI-generated sites got hit hard because the content wasn’t truly useful. Human-led SEO ensures your SaaS brand focuses on quality over quantity.

What Neil Patel Says About AI vs. Human Content

Neil Patel, in his article "AI vs Human: Who Writes Better Blogs That Get More Traffic?", dives into an interesting comparison between AI-generated and human-written content. His study found that human-written blogs pulled in 5.44 times more traffic than those created by AI.

Source: NP Digital

Even when factoring in efficiency, human-generated content still attracted more visitors per minute spent writing (4.10 visitors vs. 3.25 for AI). Patel acknowledges AI’s usefulness in speeding up content production but highlights its limitations - AI struggles to capture the emotional depth and nuanced insights that make content truly engaging. His takeaway?

AI can be a great assistant, but human creativity is still the key to crafting high-performing content.

Reddit's Take: AI vs. Human Content - The Battle Rages On

Reddit - the bustling bazaar of the internet, where experts and armchair enthusiasts alike gather to debate everything from the best pizza toppings to the future of artificial intelligence. When it comes to the AI vs. human content showdown, Redditors don't hold back.

Source: Reddit

In a lively thread on r/singularity, users dissected the evolution of AI in content creation. One user quipped, "When they say human performance, does that mean the average performance? Or is it the most capable human at that task?" .

Another chimed in, "The majority of people can't code. Beating the average human really isn't all that impressive in most tasks." .

These discussions highlight a recurring theme: while AI can mimic human writing, it often lacks the depth and authenticity that resonate with readers. As one Redditor aptly put it, "Tests designed for humans often exploit the fact that no human has read all volumes of an encyclopedia or has unlimited memory... when the same test is given to the AI... the results turn out fantastic and the AI is declared 'great improviser' even though it never improvised." .

The consensus? AI is a powerful tool, but when it comes to creating content that truly connects, there's still no substitute for the human touch. So, while your next blog post might benefit from a sprinkle of AI-generated insights, don't forget to add your unique voice - after all, that's what keeps your audience coming back for more.

AI Is Smart, But It (Still) Doesn’t Understand Your SaaS Customers Like You Do

AI can analyze vast amounts of data, spot patterns, and even predict trends (in some cases)- but here’s the catch: it doesn’t know your customers. At least, not the way you do.

SaaS companies thrive on understanding their customers' pain points, motivations, and unique behaviors. AI can gather data, but it can't interpret the emotions, challenges, or aspirations behind each search query. For example:

  • When a prospect types "how to scale my SaaS business" in the search engine, AI might suggest content on growth strategies. But do you know whether they’re a first-time founder or a seasoned entrepreneur looking for advanced tactics?
  • A search for "best CRM for customer support" could mean they’re seeking software for a small team, or perhaps an enterprise-level solution. Without human insight, AI can’t differentiate these needs.

AI can’t pick up on the nuances that come with human understanding. It can’t feel the frustration of your customers when they hit roadblocks or the excitement when they discover solutions. That’s where you come in.

As a SaaS expert, you know:

  • What keeps your customers up at night.
  • The exact language they use when discussing their challenges.
  • How they make decisions when it comes to purchasing.

AI simply processes data - it doesn’t experience your customer journey. This is why human expertise is critical in creating SEO content that resonates. By understanding your audience at a deeper level, you can craft messaging that speaks directly to their needs, builds trust, and ultimately converts them into loyal customers.

AI as a Partner, Not a Replacement

AI is an incredible asset, but it’s most effective when used strategically. Think of it like a calculator - it can process complex calculations faster than you can, but it still requires input and context to deliver the right results. Rather than using AI just to create more content, leverage it to:

  • Analyze vast amounts of SEO data.
  • Identify emerging trends and opportunities.
  • Generate content drafts that humans refine and optimize.

When AI is paired with human creativity and expertise, it becomes a powerful force for SEO success. By feeding AI the right information and using it to enhance, rather than replace, human input, SaaS companies can create smarter, more effective SEO strategies that drive real results.

Partner

Michael Ter Mors

Michael is a Partner at Conifr and oversees operations. Michael has been in web development, digital marketing, and analytics for nearly two decades, with experience running agencies and leading in-house marketing teams. He has led integrated digital marketing teams for both paid search and SEO across household name brands, such as Norwegian Cruise Line and 1-800-Pack-Rat. Michael specializes in strategy, business development, and analytics. Before Conifr, Michael was the Chief Marketing Officer at a sustainability focused online gaming startup.